Preliminary note: This is not an official Splinterlands proposal but a proposal to launch such a proposal via the DAO with the opportunity for all Hive users to express their opinion beforehand.
Brawl - Count all frays equally
Now a guild can just leave a fray empty and the result against all other guilds in this fray will be 0:0, it even happens in the past that frays was only filled from one guild, so this guild could reach only 0 points in this fray.
Improvement: All frays count for every guild, so if a guild let a fray empty this counts as 3 points for all guilds who filled this fray. A 0:0 would be only in affect anymore when two guilds doesn't fill the same fray (so it is logical that both cannot win any point).
PROs:
- Guilds are encouraged to fill all Frays.
- Each guild member can contribute something to the overall result.
- With more fights per Brawl, it's more exciting to participate
CONTRAs:
- Guilds with few members cannot fill all Frays
Further information
As shown in this screenshot, even a level 1 guild already has 15 member positions, so 15 members can join a guild:
On the other hand, a level 1 (and also level 2) arena only offers 13 Frays, so that with a full level 1 guild, 2 members cannot take part in the brawl:
It cannot happen that a guild has a lower membership limit than the Frays that have to be filled in a Brawl, since the arena can never have a higher level than the Guild Hall.
